You finish an email, spot the one line your coworker absolutely cannot miss, and underline it. On their screen, that line now looks exactly like a link. They tap it. Nothing happens.
That small moment of confusion is the whole problem with underlining for emphasis, and it has a close cousin: the sentence typed in ALL CAPS.
Why an underlined word reads like a broken link
Online, underlining has one job. The U.S. government’s own plain language guide points out that readers expect underlined text to be a clickable link, which is why it advises against using underlining for emphasis in anything read on a screen.
Think about how you read your own inbox. Underlined words mean “click here.” When an underlined phrase does nothing, the reader has to stop and figure out what went wrong. Your emphasis gets noticed, but for the wrong reason.
In an email, a chat message, or a shared doc, underlining sends a signal you did not mean to send: “this goes somewhere.”
ALL CAPS has the same problem, only louder
Most people type in capitals because it feels like the most attention-grabbing option available. The same guide says the opposite is true: text in ALL CAPS is actually harder to read.
Compare these two lines from a team update:
- PLEASE SUBMIT YOUR TIMESHEET BEFORE THE END OF THE DAY
- Please submit your timesheet before the end of the day
The first one takes longer to get through, even though it is the exact same sentence. The second one is quick to read, and the part that matters still jumps off the screen.
So the capitals do not buy you attention. They cost your reader time, which is the one thing a busy person reading email does not have.
What to use instead of underlining and capitals
The fix is simple and already sitting in your toolbar. For emphasis, the guide recommends bold or italics, which do the job much better than capitals or underlining.
Use bold for the one thing the reader must not miss: a deadline, an amount, a decision. Use italics for a lighter touch, like a single word you want to stress in a sentence. Keep both rare, since a paragraph where everything is bold has no emphasis left at all.
Formatting habits that make any email easier to read
Emphasis is only one part of it. The same plain language guide, written for federal websites, offers a few habits that carry over directly to a work email or a short report:
- Put the key information at the top. Do not bury the most important point at the end of the message.
- Use clear, descriptive headings in longer documents, and use them consistently so the structure makes sense at a glance.
- Use lists and tables on purpose. Lists make a message easy to scan, and tables help when you are comparing several things at once.
The guide sums up the risk of skipping all this in one line: “dense, cluttered writing deters people from taking the time to read.” In other words, a wall of text is not just unattractive. It is a reason for someone to put off reading your message.
The rule to remember before you hit send
Before sending, scan your email for two things: any underlined text that is not a real link, and any word or sentence typed in capitals for effect. Turn both into bold, and keep the bold for the single detail your reader cannot afford to miss.
A good test: if it is underlined, it should be clickable, and if it matters, it should be bold, not shouting.

