Picture two emails landing in your manager’s inbox. One is flawless, every comma in place, and it gets back a confused “Sorry, what do you need from me?” The other has a typo in the second line, and it gets a one-word reply: “Approved.”
The difference has nothing to do with grammar. It comes down to what each writer chose to fix first.
Why a spotless email can still miss the mark
Most of us revise a work email from the bottom up. We hunt for typos, swap a word or two, check the commas, and hit send.
Purdue OWL, the online writing lab run by Purdue University, recommends the opposite order. Its guide to prioritizing your concerns in business writing separates “higher order concerns” (the big-picture questions) from surface issues like grammar and punctuation, and the big questions come first.
The logic is simple. A perfectly written message that is badly aimed at its reader is still an ineffective message. Clean sentences cannot rescue an email that never says what it wants.
Purdue describes professional writing as “action-oriented, rhetorical, and user-centered.” In plain terms, it exists to get something done, for a specific person.
The two emails, side by side
Here is the polished version that went nowhere:
Polished but unfocused: “Hi Dana, I hope your week is going well. I wanted to share a few thoughts about our current scheduling tool, which has been causing some friction across the team lately. There are several alternatives on the market that could be worth exploring at some point.”
And here is the one that got approved:
Imperfect but aimed: “Hi Dana, can you approve a paid plan for a new sheduling tool? Our current one double-booked three client calls last week. I’d like to switch by the 15th, and I can send a quick comparison of two options if that helps.”
Yes, “scheduling” is misspelled in the second one. It still works, because Dana knows exactly what to approve, why, and by when. The first email is grammatically spotless and never asks for anything.
That does not mean typos are fine. It means they are the last thing to fix, not the first.
The four priorities, in the right order
Purdue ranks what to work on before you ever get to the commas:
- Focus and purpose. Ask yourself “What is your purpose in writing the document?” before you even start. Every other choice follows from the answer.
- Audience. Write for the actual person who will read it, not a generic reader. Someone approving a budget needs different details than a teammate who uses the tool every day.
- Organization and format. Lead with your main point, then use headings or bullet points where they make the message easier to follow.
- Development. Give enough evidence (a concrete example, a number, a chart), answer the questions your reader is likely to ask, and stay concise.
Notice what is missing from that list: grammar and punctuation. They still matter, but they come after all four.
Three habits that put polish ahead of purpose
- Fine-tuning the wording of an email before checking that it has a clear goal
- Writing for “anyone” instead of the person who will actually open it
- Skipping visual structure entirely, with no bullets and no headings, even when the message covers several points
The last one surprises people. In Purdue’s ranking, the way a message is organized shapes how clear it feels just as much as what it says. A wall of text with a perfect main point can still read as confusing.
Proofreading still has its moment, of course. If you want to get that final pass right, here is why sleeping on an important email actually works.
Revise from the top down
Before you touch a single comma, answer two questions in one sentence each. What do I want this person to do? Who exactly is going to read this?
If you cannot answer both, no amount of proofreading will save the email. If you can, put the answer to the first one in your opening line, and only then go looking for typos.
The rule to remember: purpose first, reader second, structure third, evidence fourth, grammar last.

