Somewhere along the way, most of us were told never to write “I” in an essay. So we twist sentences into knots to avoid it, and the paper ends up vaguer than if we had simply said who did what.
The no-I rule was good advice that grew too strict
The University of North Carolina Writing Center tackles this exact question in its guide Should I use “I”? It traces the ban back to the classroom: students pick up strict rules from teachers and from each other, and many of those rules started as “good advice” before hardening into “unnecessarily strict rules” in students’ minds.
The trouble with a rule that rigid is that it stops you from adapting. A lab report, a history paper and a film response do not follow the same conventions, and a blanket ban treats them as if they did.
What dodging I does to a sentence
Here is a sentence from someone working very hard to avoid the first person:
“In studying American popular culture of the 1980s, the question of to what degree materialism was a major characteristic of the cultural milieu was explored.”
Explored by whom? The sentence never says, and it takes a second read to find the point. UNC’s revision simply brings the writers back in:
“In our study of American popular culture of the 1980s, we explored the degree to which materialism characterized the cultural milieu.”
Same idea, fewer detours, and the reader knows exactly who did the exploring. If the first version reminds you of the habit we covered in passive voice belongs in your methods section, not your argument, that is no coincidence: hiding the actor is often how writers avoid saying “I.”
UNC lists three situations where the first person earns its place. Use it to be assertive about who is doing what, or about the value of your own project. Use it to keep a sentence clear instead of awkward. And use it to position yourself, showing how your work builds on or departs from what others have written.
Where I really does get in the way
The opposite mistake is just as common. When you describe something meant to be objective, “I” pulls the spotlight onto you instead of the finding.
Compare “As I was reading this study of medieval village life, I noticed that social class tended to be clearly defined” with UNC’s version: “This study of medieval village life reveals that social class tended to be clearly defined.” The finding belongs to the study, not to the moment you happened to read it.
Then there is the phrase that weakens more essays than any pronoun ban ever did. UNC’s example: “I think that Aristotle’s ethical arguments are logical and readily applicable to contemporary cases, or at least it seems that way to me.” Cut the hedge and you get a claim that stands on its own: “Aristotle’s ethical arguments are logical and readily applicable to contemporary cases.”
Your reader already assumes the ideas in your paper are yours. Phrases like “I think,” “I feel” and “I believe” are often used, in UNC’s words, “as if such a phrase could replace a real defense of an argument.” They can’t. What persuades is the evidence that follows a claim, not the announcement that you hold it.
Your field changes the answer
Conventions are not the same everywhere. The sciences have traditionally avoided “I” to suggest objectivity, although that is shifting, especially when you describe your own project or place it within existing research. The social sciences increasingly accept it for the same purposes. In the humanities, which value assertiveness and agency, “I” is often, though not always, appropriate.
One pronoun stays risky almost everywhere: “you.” It usually sounds too conversational in academic writing, so UNC suggests “one,” “the reader” or “people” instead. And when you are genuinely unsure about “I,” the guide’s advice is refreshingly simple: ask your instructor.
The two-question check before you submit
Find every “I” in your draft and ask two questions. Does it make the sentence clearer, or tell the reader who did something? Keep it. Is it sitting in front of a finding, or propping up a claim with “I think”? Cut it and let the evidence do the talking.
The rule to remember: use “I” to say what you did, never to replace proof of what you claim.

