“Since the dawn of man, slavery has been a problem in human history.” That is a real example of an essay opening from the UNC Writing Center, and it is there as a warning. Instructors, the Center says, “often find them extremely annoying.”
The “dawn of man” opener is only one of five introductions that look like writing but do none of the work an introduction is supposed to do.
What an introduction is actually for
According to the UNC Writing Center, your opening paragraph is a road map. It tells readers what your topic is, why it matters and how you plan to proceed. After reading it, they should have no major surprises in store when they reach the body of your paper.
It is also your first impression. As the Center puts it, “You never get a second chance to make a first impression.”
Five openings that say almost nothing
Here are the five weak types UNC describes, with a quick way to spot each one.
1. The placeholder. Several vague sentences that exist only to fill the space. “There were many different aspects of slavery. Each created different kinds of problems.” If you had something sharper to say, you would have said it.
2. The restated question. You copy the assignment prompt back in slightly different words. Your instructor wrote that question and will read it in many essays, so they “do not need to read a whole paragraph that simply restates the question.”
3. The dictionary opening. “Webster’s dictionary defines…” Anyone can look up a word, the dictionary knows nothing about your course, and the move is so overused that it has lost its punch. UNC suggests defining the term in the context of your assignment, or borrowing a definition from one of your course readings.
4. The “dawn of man.” Sweeping claims about “throughout human history” that never connect to your thesis. UNC says it is “hard to imagine a time when starting with one of these would work.”
5. The book report. Title, author, publisher, and what the book is about. Your reader almost certainly knows all of it, and none of it supports your argument.
Try this: the friend test
UNC offers a simple check. Ask a friend to read your introduction, then tell you what they expect the paper to discuss, what kind of evidence it will use and what the tone will be.
If your friend predicts the rest of your paper accurately, you probably have a good introduction. If they shrug, you may have one of the five above.
What to do instead
Start from the question you are answering, and decide how broad your opening should be. UNC compares it to a map: you zoom out to the whole globe only if your question is about the globe. For most essays, the right level is a city or a state, not the galaxy.
Then open with something that draws readers in. The Center lists a few options, though they may not suit every kind of paper: an intriguing example, a provocative quotation tied to your argument, a puzzling scenario, a vivid anecdote or a thought-provoking question.
One more tip from the Center: try writing your introduction last. You may not know exactly what you are arguing until the draft is done. Write a tentative opening if it helps you start, then go back and rewrite it once your argument is clear. It pairs well with the advice on writing a thesis you can keep and on endings that do not undo your argument.
Remember this: before you finalize your first paragraph, ask whether it could open any essay on any topic. If it could, rewrite it until it could only open yours.

