4.4/5 - (42 votes)

Grab three highlighters and print your essay. Mark every general claim in yellow, every quote, statistic or example in blue, and every sentence that explains what the evidence means in green. If the page is mostly blue, you are not arguing yet.

That test comes from the UNC Writing Center, and it exposes a habit that many writers share: collecting good evidence and then trusting it to do the talking.

Evidence never speaks for itself

The Center is blunt about it. Does evidence speak for itself? “Absolutely not.” A fact only becomes evidence when it is connected to a larger claim, because “evidence is always evidence for or against something.”

Readers cannot read your mind. They may know the facts, but they do not know what you are trying to do with them unless you say so.

The plop quotation

UNC has a name for the most common version of this mistake: the plop quotation. It is a quote “just dropped into your paper without any introduction, discussion, or follow-up.”

There is an easy way to spot one. If a paragraph ends with a quotation, you may have skipped the part where you explain why it matters.

Compare these two versions:

Plopped: Remote work is changing offices. “Most employees now prefer a hybrid schedule.” Companies are adjusting.

Explained: Remote work is changing offices. One survey line says “most employees now prefer a hybrid schedule,” which means a company that demands five days in person is asking people to give up something most of them want. That is the cost the next section weighs.

See also  Ignoring the other side is what quietly weakens your essay

The second version introduces the evidence, then tells the reader what to do with it. (The survey line is an invented illustration, not a real statistic.)

Five questions that turn a fact into an argument

UNC suggests asking yourself about each piece of evidence:

  • I just stated this, but so what? Why should anyone care?
  • What does this information imply?
  • Why is it important?
  • How does it connect to my thesis?
  • Can I give an example?

If you cannot answer, the sentence is probably a “laundry list” item, the kind of thing instructors flag with comments like “for example?” or “go deeper.”

Read your colors

Back to the highlighters. UNC’s rule of thumb is that “you should have at least as much analysis as you do evidence, or your paper runs the risk of being more summary than argument.”

So count the green. A page with plenty of yellow and blue but almost no green is a report. A page where every blue block is followed by green is an argument.

The Center adds one more guide: the more controversial a claim is, the more evidence you may need to persuade your reader.

Borrow a skeptical friend

If you have no highlighters, recruit a person. UNC suggests reading your essay aloud to a friend who plays devil’s advocate, or who acts like a child and questions every sentence, even the obvious ones. Explaining your point out loud shows you exactly where the explanation is missing.

Not sure how to introduce a quote in the first place? See 8 citation verbs that tell your reader what a source really thinks, and for putting sources in your own words, why swapping a few words does not count as paraphrasing.

See also  Not every fact in your essay needs a citation, and here is the test

The rule to remember

After every quote, write at least one sentence that starts with “This shows” or “This matters because.” If you cannot finish that sentence, either the evidence does not belong or your argument has a gap.