“Somebody left their umbrella in the office.” Read that sentence again. Does it sound wrong to you? If a teacher ever told you it does, the history says otherwise.
The “error” that is older than the rule
Singular they means using they, them or their for one person, as in “Somebody should let you borrow their book.” It sounds like a modern habit. It is not.
According to Wikipedia’s overview of the topic, they was already being used this way by the 14th century, only about a century after plural they arrived in English from Old Norse. It has been in use ever since.
The rule against it came later. Critics began calling it an error in the mid-18th century. The earliest explicit recommendation to use he instead is credited to Ann Fisher’s A New Grammar, which argued that “the Masculine Person answers to the general Name.”
Why he won for a while
By the 19th century, grammarians insisted on he for a person of unknown gender, because it kept the pronoun singular like its noun. They also rejected “he or she” as clumsy. In 1850, a British act of Parliament even declared that words importing the masculine gender include females.
Writers mostly ignored all this. A 1895 school grammar still quotes authors using sentences like “Every one must judge according to their own feelings.” And when the Chicago Manual of Style endorsed singular they in 1993, it pointed to its “venerable use by such writers as Addison, Austen, Chesterfield, Fielding, Ruskin, Scott, and Shakespeare.”
What you probably say out loud already
Try these in conversation:
- “Everyone brought their laptop.”
- “If anybody calls, tell them I’ll be back at three.”
- “Someone forgot their keys.”
You almost certainly said something like that this week. A study of the British National Corpus found that speakers of every age, background and region used they with words like everybody and anybody more often than they used he.
What today’s style guides say
The big guides have moved, though not all at the same speed:
- APA (7th edition, 2019): use singular they when gender is unknown or irrelevant. Its example: “I don’t know who wrote this note, but they have good handwriting.”
- Chicago (17th edition): Bryan Garner notes that “resistance to the singular they is fast receding.”
- AP Stylebook (2017): acceptable “when alternative wording is overly awkward or clumsy. However, rewording usually is possible and always is preferable.”
The Washington Post took a similar line in 2015: rewrite first, and use singular they as a last resort. By 2020, most major style guides accepted it.
Two details that trip people up
The verb stays plural. Singular they takes the same verb forms as plural they: “They have good handwriting,” not “they has.” That is why the sentence feels odd to some readers, even though it follows the pattern you use for you (“you are,” even when talking to one person).
Reflexive forms are still unsettled. Themselves is the safe choice. Themself is attested from the 14th to the 16th centuries and has been rising since the 1970s or 1980s, but it is still a minority form.
The takeaway for your next email
For an unknown person, singular they is established English, and “he or she” is no longer required. In a formal document, check which guide your reader follows. If you want to sidestep the question completely, try the AP trick and rewrite the sentence in the plural: “Employees should bring their badges” instead of “Each employee should bring his or her badge.”
One rule to remember: use they for someone unknown, keep the verb plural, and rewrite only when the sentence gets clumsy.
Curious about another rule with a shaky reputation? See the made-up grammar rule one 18th-century writer invented, or why its has no apostrophe.

