Someone in your group chat says banning one type of car will “obviously” lead to banning every car on the road, and everyone just moves on like that argument actually proved something.
It didn’t. That’s a slippery slope, one of several logical fallacies that show up constantly in online arguments and just as often in student essays, according to Purdue OWL’s breakdown of common reasoning errors in academic writing.
The straw man that wins without actually winning
A straw man argument shrinks someone’s real position into a weaker, easier version, then attacks that version instead. Claiming that anyone who supports a small raise “just hates business owners” is a straw man: it swaps a specific, reasonable request for an extreme one nobody actually made.
It feels like a win because the fake version is so easy to knock down. The real position never gets touched, and in an essay, a grader notices the gap immediately.
Just because b came after a doesn’t mean a caused b
Purdue OWL calls this post hoc ergo propter hoc, literally “after this, therefore because of this.” Blaming a stomach bug on the last thing you ate for dinner, without checking anything else you touched that day, is the textbook version.
Online, this shows up in almost every cause-and-effect claim backed by nothing but timing. One thing happened after another, so the first thing gets blamed, no evidence required. The same shortcut in a research paper reads as a claim with no actual support behind it.
The circular argument that sounds like proof
A circular argument just restates the claim instead of proving it. Saying someone is a great communicator because they communicate effectively doesn’t add any evidence, it repeats the same idea in different words and hopes nobody notices.
These arguments can sound confident, even smart, because the sentence itself is grammatically fine. The logic inside it just never actually goes anywhere, which is exactly why it’s so easy to leave one sitting in a thesis statement without realizing it.
The two shortcuts hiding in almost every hot take
Hasty generalization is judging something big, an entire class, a whole group, a full season of a show, off a single example. One rude customer service call doesn’t mean a company is bad at customer service, it means one call went badly.
Ad hominem is attacking the person instead of the argument, like dismissing an organization’s strategy by mocking how its members look or talk. It feels satisfying to type. It answers nothing, and it tells a reader you’ve run out of actual points to make.
The one question that catches all of them before you hit send
Every fallacy above is far easier to spot in someone else’s argument than in your own, which is exactly why it slips past you in a live draft, whether that’s a reply or a research paper.
Before you submit a paper, or post a reply you feel a little too proud of, ask one question: does this sentence add real evidence, or does it just restate the claim in a more confident tone? If it’s the second one, the argument isn’t finished yet, no matter how sure it sounds.

