4.6/5 - (45 votes)

“The manager or the interns are handling it.” “The interns or the manager is handling it.” Both sentences are correct, and the only thing that changed the verb is which word happens to sit next to it.

That looks like a typo waiting to happen. It is actually one of the most practical shortcuts in English grammar, and once you see why it exists, you will stop second-guessing your emails.

The rule everyone knows, until the subject has two parts

The basic idea is simple: the subject and the verb have to agree in number. One person is, two people are. Nobody struggles with that.

The trouble starts with a compound subject, which just means a subject made of more than one item, like “the book or the pen” or “she and her friends.” Here is how it works, following the Purdue OWL guide on making subjects and verbs agree:

  • Two items joined by and take a plural verb: “She and her friends are at the fair.”
  • Two singular items joined by or or nor take a singular verb: “The book or the pen is in the drawer.”
  • One singular and one plural item joined by or or nor: the verb agrees with the item closest to it.

That last line is the strange one. Purdue gives a pair of examples that look almost contradictory side by side: “The boy or his friends run every day” and “His friends or the boy runs every day.” Same people, same activity, different verb.

Why English lets the nearest word decide

The word “and” is easy to count. Two things joined by “and” are two things, so the verb goes plural.

See also  This missing comma cost a company millions of dollars in court

The word “or” is different. It offers a choice, so it does not tell you how many people are actually doing the action. Is it one boy running, or several friends? The sentence genuinely does not say.

English has no general rule to settle that kind of mixed singular-plural choice, so it takes a pragmatic shortcut: the word nearest the verb gets to decide. It is less a law of logic than a practical fix for a real ambiguity.

In a work email, that might look like this:

  • Correct: “Either the slides or the report is due Friday.”
  • Correct: “Either the report or the slides are due Friday.”

If the plural version sounds more natural to you, put the plural item last. That is usually the smoothest option.

The words that try to steal the verb

The nearest-word shortcut only applies to “or” and “nor.” Everywhere else, words that sit between the subject and the verb are decoys, and they cause some of the most common agreement mistakes in long sentences.

Phrases like “as well as”

Purdue’s example: “The team captain, as well as his players, is anxious.” It looks wrong because “players” is right next to the verb. But the subject is still “the team captain,” so the verb stays singular. Unlike “and,” a phrase like “as well as” does not turn the subject plural.

“One of” and “each of”

“One of the boxes is open.” The real subject is “one,” not “boxes.” The same goes for “Each of these hot dogs is juicy.” Words like each, either, neither and everyone are always singular.

See also  The 'affect vs effect' mistake almost everyone makes

Sentences that start with “there is”

In a “there is” or “there are” sentence, the real subject comes after the verb. So “There is many questions” should be “There are many questions.” It is easy to type “there is” on autopilot before you have decided what comes next.

Nouns that only look plural

Some words end in -s but are grammatically singular: “The news is on at six.” Mathematics, civics and measles work the same way. Others, like scissors and trousers, are always plural.

The quick test to use before you hit send

When a sentence has a two-part subject, ask one question: is it joined by “and,” or by “or”?

If it is “and,” go plural. If it is “or” or “nor,” look at the word right before the verb and match it. And if anything else sits between the subject and the verb (as well as, one of, each of), cover it with your finger and read the sentence again. Whatever is left is the subject your verb has to agree with.