4.9/5 - (51 votes)

In 2017, a dairy company in Maine lost a court case over a single missing comma, and had to pay its delivery drivers millions of dollars because of it.

What actually happened

A group of truck drivers sued their employer, Oakhurst Dairy, arguing they were owed years of overtime pay. The whole case came down to one sentence in Maine’s labor law, listing the tasks that did not qualify for overtime: “canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, packing for shipment or distribution of” perishable food.

No comma sits before “or distribution.” So the drivers argued the law exempted “packing for shipment or distribution,” not “packing for shipment” and “distribution” as two separate things. Since the drivers distributed food but never packed it, that missing comma meant the exemption did not apply to them at all.

The comma at the center of it all

That single comma is called the Oxford comma, or serial comma: the comma placed before “and” or “or” in a list of three or more items. “Red, white, and blue” has one. “Red, white and blue” does not.

Most people assume it is either always required or always optional. It is neither. Academic and editorial styles like Chicago and Oxford use it every time. Journalistic style, including AP style used by most US newspapers, drops it. Maine’s law happened to follow AP style, and that stylistic choice is exactly what cost the company its case.

When it actually matters

Most lists never need it. “I bought apples, bread and milk” is perfectly clear either way. The comma only earns its place when a list contains a pair, a description, or an “or” that could be read two ways.

See also  Why English still has whom when almost every other ending vanished

Compare these two sentences:

“I’d like to thank my parents, Oprah and God” reads as if your parents are Oprah and God.
“I’d like to thank my parents, Oprah, and God” makes it clear they are three separate people.

Same words, same order, one comma changes who your parents are.

The rule to actually remember

You do not need to pick a side in the great comma debate. You need one habit: before you send anything with a list of three or more items, read it once pretending the last two items could be grouped together. If that reading is even a little bit possible, add the comma. It costs you one character and it is the exact habit that would have saved Oakhurst Dairy several million dollars.