You text a classmate, “Hi! Y’all done stuff like this before?” and it reads perfectly. Paste that same line into the first paragraph of an essay, and your professor sees something else entirely: a draft that never left the group chat.
Nothing in that sentence is a secret code. Everyone understands it. That is exactly why the problem is so easy to miss.
Formality is a dial, not a single correct setting
It is tempting to think there is one “proper” way to write and everything else is sloppy. The Online Writing Lab at Purdue University describes it differently. In its guide to levels of formality, it says “the level of formality you write with should be determined by the expectations of your audience and your purpose.”
So formality works more like a volume dial than a rulebook. A text to a friend sits at one end. A message to a coworker you know well sits somewhere in the middle. A college essay or a cover letter sits at the formal end, and that is the setting your reader expects to find when they open the document.
If you have ever wondered how to figure out who your reader is and what your writing is for, we covered that in knowing your topic is not the same as knowing your purpose. Formality is one of the first places those two questions show up on the page.
The opening Purdue marks as incorrect
Purdue gives a sample that it labels plainly as “Incorrect” for formal writing. It contains three habits that feel completely natural in everyday messages:
- A casual greeting: opening with “Hi!” the way you would start an email to a friend
- A regional or colloquial word: “y’all,” which works out loud and in texts but not in formal writing
- A loose, spoken phrase: “done stuff like it,” which sounds like conversation rather than a written argument
None of these are grammar errors in a chat. They are register errors in an essay. Register simply means the level of formality your words carry. “Hey, can you send that over?” and “Could you please send the file?” ask for the same thing in two different registers.
Clear and casual are not the same thing
This is where many careful writers get tripped up. They are told to be direct and plain, so they write the way they talk. But being clear is recommended, and being casual is a different thing altogether.
Compare these two sentences:
Casual: “Y’all might think school uniforms are no big deal, but they’ve done stuff like this at my old school and it was kind of a mess.”
Formal and still clear: “Many people see school uniforms as a minor issue, but my former school’s uniform policy created several problems.”
The second version is not longer or fancier. It just drops the greeting-style address, the regional word and the vague spoken phrase. As we explained in big words are not what makes an essay sound academic, a formal tone comes from what you leave out, not from rare vocabulary.
The middle setting, and why it is not for essays
Purdue also describes a semi-formal level, the kind of writing you might use with colleagues you already know. It allows slightly more relaxed language than strict formal writing.
That middle setting is useful. It is often the right choice for a quick note to a teammate. But it is not the register expected for an academic submission. An essay, a research paper and a cover letter share the same expectation of formal language, whatever the subject happens to be.
And this is not about trying to sound smart. It is about meeting the expectations of the context you are writing in.
A quick test before you submit
Read your first paragraph and ask one question: would this line sound natural in a text message to a friend?
If the answer is yes, check three things. Remove any greeting like “Hi!” or “Hey there.” Replace regional or colloquial words with plain standard ones. Turn vague spoken phrases like “stuff like it” into the specific thing you mean.
The rule to keep: write clearly enough for a stranger to follow, and formally enough for the document you are writing. Clear is always welcome. Casual depends on who is reading.

