You’ve seen it on a farm stand sign: “apple’s for sale,” with an apostrophe that has no business being there. It’s such a common slip that it actually has a nickname among editors, and once you notice it, you’ll spot it everywhere.
The mistake that earned its own name
Editors call it the “grocer’s apostrophe,” the habit of sticking an apostrophe into a plain plural noun like it’s automatically needed. “Apple’s for sale” should just be “apples for sale.” No apostrophe, no possession, no contraction, just more than one apple.
The apostrophe only has three real jobs in English: showing possession (“the boy’s hat”), marking missing letters in a contraction (“don’t,” “who’s”), and pluralizing lowercase letters standing alone (“mind your p’s and q’s”). A regular plural noun isn’t on that list, which is exactly why “apple’s” and “banana’s” look off to anyone who knows the rule, even if they can’t say why.
Correct vs incorrect, side by side
Possessives are where most of the real confusion lives. A singular noun, even one that already ends in s, takes ‘s: “James’s hat.” A plural that doesn’t end in s also takes ‘s: “the children’s game.” But a plural that already ends in s takes just an apostrophe, no extra s: “two cats’ toys.”
The trickiest pair is “it’s” versus “its.” “It’s” always means “it is” or “it has.” “Its” is the possessive, and like his, hers, and theirs, it never gets an apostrophe. “The group made its decision” is correct. “The group made it’s decision” is not, even though it looks tempting.
Same pattern with “who’s” and “whose.” “Who’s coming to the meeting?” means “who is.” “Whose idea was this?” is possessive, no apostrophe. Mixing them up is one of the most common apostrophe errors in work emails.
The one time a plural does get an apostrophe
Here’s the twist: “mind your p’s and q’s” is a real, correct use of an apostrophe on a plural, because it’s pluralizing single lowercase letters, not a regular word. Without the apostrophe, “ps and qs” is genuinely hard to read at a glance.
The phrase itself may trace back to the early days of printing, when letters were set in lead type and placed backward so they’d print correctly on the page. A lowercase p and a lowercase q are mirror images of each other, and a typesetter reading them in reverse could easily grab the wrong one. Getting your p’s and q’s right meant paying close attention to a small detail that was easy to flip by mistake, which is exactly how the phrase came to mean “watch the details.”
So the “p’s and q’s” apostrophe isn’t an exception that breaks the rule. It’s the rule working exactly as intended, just on letters instead of words.
The rule to keep
Before you type an apostrophe, ask what job it’s doing. If it’s not showing possession and it’s not standing in for missing letters in a contraction, it almost certainly doesn’t belong, and a plain plural noun almost never needs one.

